Rarely do you see a comparison of CAD programs. Most are Pro/e clones and virtually work identically except for a few small differences.
I don't particularly care for speed comparisons of CAD systems. We don't design for speed. Design can be a time consuming process involving many considerations. But we also do not want the CAD system to get in our way and become an obstacle in our design process.
Pay attention to the stark difference in the two design paradigms.
I have rarely used the Pro/e constrained sketching paradigm. But as I look at the person design this part in SW I wonder if that is the best way. I notice that he/she has created the complete sketch for the part. I would have created the large rectangle then the rectangular cut and the holes separately, like I would in IronCAD. It seems like you would have more control. But then that would have been another separate step.
My experience with the Pro/e paradigm has been a bit limited due to its overly complex process.
I have used Pro/e to convert some drawings to solid models and did attempt a real project in SW. In the SW project, I used the top down or in context design which is the way you design in IronCAD. I used some existing parts that I imported for reference. I soon had a corrupt assembly and I could not get some edges to be recognized to project on a sketch to create a new part. I gave up. Considering my extensive CAD experience, you would think the package would be intuitive enough to allow me to figure it out.
Change has always been the enemy of the Pro/e clone.
If you use Creo, NX, Catia, Solidworks, Solid Edge, Inventor or any other Pro/E Clone!
Do not watch this video and do not "ever" let the boss see it!
Design Faster, Better, & Easier with IronCAD
IronCAD’s new Mechanical Add-In (IronCAD Mechanical) offers intelligent tools for fabricators such as Industry Standard fasteners, steel sections, piping, flanges, bill of material generation and much more. Because knowledge and behavior is built directly into the intelligent components, typical day-to-day tasks are much simpler and this significantly reduces design time especially for fabricators. IronCAD has announced that the base level proven functionality will be included free of charge to all customers (which includes Fasteners, Custom Holes, Bearings, Steels, O-rings, retaining rings, and Boss Threads).
Please notice that we are working in a Single Model Environment! Even without Mechanical, IronCAD is the most productive fabrication program available.
We sell and support IronCAD
and ZW3D Products and provide
engineering services throughout the USA and Canada!
If you are interested in adding professional
hybrid modeling capabilities or looking for a new solution to
increase your productivity, take some time to download a fully
functional 30 day evaluation and play with these packages. Feel free
to give me a call if you have any questions or would like an on-line
WARNING: ZW3D is a professional 3D CAD engineering package and
it is not recommended for those who are not engineering
professionals or students with no prior 3D CAD experience. While
we will help you get started we are not equipped at this price
to teach you 3D CAD from scratch or engineering design. Don't
let this low price fool you.